A few weeks ago, E asked if she could have some friends over to carve pumpkins. Last year, we coincidentally ended up with at least one extra kid on our pumpkin-carving night,* and it was a lot of fun. Additionally, I’ve had a few occasions in the past several weeks to hang out with the girls’ friends, and I find those times valuable. Especially with E, as she’s stretching and flexing, socially, and has switched her friendships all around. She’s now hanging out with girls that I’ve only known of tangentially in the past.
So I said yes.
And of course, J said, “me too! me too!”
E wanted to invite 4 or 5 people, and J wanted to invite 3. That’s too many knives in too many hands for me to deal with at once. I also am not too keen on shoving 8th grade humor and conversation topics into 6th grade brains. It’s enough to have J sitting there wide-eyed at the older girls’ jokes and vocabulary (I’m thinking in particular of the word “horny”) – I don’t need to do it to three other “little” girls.
“Let’s have two groups, then,” I said. [who, me, insane? nah] E on Saturday night, and J on Sunday afternoon. We told D of our plans, he looked at me like I had three heads, and then he shrugged and said okay.
Both gatherings were very low-key. I had kids bring their own pumpkins (and laughed disproportionately and often at the phrase “B.Y.O.P.”), ordered a couple of pizzas, and put out M & M’s. The kids pulled out their iPods and the radio, and they laughed and carved and did not cut themselves even once. (Phew.) I enjoyed all the kids, even though my own eyes popped out of my own head a few times at some of the conversations and activities (of both the 11 and 13 year olds). All in all, it was a success.
Until later on Sunday evening. When a parent called because her daughter hadn’t been invited to our party. It was a parent that I like, and the parent of a child that is much-loved in our home.
But when choosing who to invite, both the girls worked hard to make sure that their chosen friends “meshed” with one another, that the chosen friends would be interested in the activity, and that the numbers didn’t exceed the limits I set (and I did allow for less 11 year olds than 13 year olds, because of the increased supervision required). Neither of them invited all of their friends.
My first reaction was to say, “well, it wasn’t really a ‘party’ – we just had a few people over.” I explained that I couldn’t have large numbers, since we were playing with knives and all. Apparently, the parent had heard from one of the invitees that we had 7-10 people over at one time. Names were even shared – names of girls who were not at our house, and were not invited.
The parent was embarrassed when I explained what we really did that day (i.e., not a party), and apologized profusely. But I still feel crappy about it.
Not really sure what my take-away is:
- if you’re going to have less than everybody at your house, you must swear the invited ones to secrecy;
- you may either invite ONE child to your home, or every single one of your child’s friends; anything in between is an affront to others; or
- we are going to piss people off, no matter what.
We didn’t tell our kid that her friend was upset, or anything about the phone call. I was full of angst for the entire evening. D tried to calm me down and let me know that we did nothing wrong, that we couldn’t have 20 kids over at a time for this particular activity. We don’t have the space, and we didn’t have the required supervision. And buying pizza and M&Ms for 4 or 5 is a far cry from a full-blown “party” for 20.
I’m not tortured over it anymore, but I am wondering if I missed something. If there is this unspoken rule in our town that small gatherings are not okay. If it’s the case, we may have to move, because my kids [and their mother] don’t like huge gatherings. They prefer to have a few people over at a time.
I still don’t know what the take-away is, and I don’t know if we’ll be doing this again next year. Which is too bad, because we had a great time.
* I do not remember carving pumpkins with my family of origin. As an adult, however, the fall is my favorite time of year – I love the colors, the smell, the cool, and Halloween is an essential element of that season. When the girls were very little, when I was a single mom, we first started decorating (not yet carving) pumpkins. I know that we carved – with knives and everything – starting in 2004, our first year back on the East Coast. It’s become an essential autumnal tradition in our family.